{
  "release_id": "a25293eeae6350fb",
  "id": "cardio:closure-of-pfo-and-asd",
  "owner": "cardio",
  "kind": "intervention",
  "slug": "closure-of-pfo-and-asd",
  "name": "Closure of atrial septal defect and patent foramen ovale",
  "aliases": [
    "PFO closure",
    "ASD closure",
    "Septal closure"
  ],
  "atlases": [
    "cardio"
  ],
  "summary_plain": "Closing an atrial septal defect or a patent foramen ovale means shutting the opening between the two upper chambers of the heart, with a catheter-delivered implant or by surgery. MeSH describes a septal occluder device as a catheter-delivered implant used for closing abnormal holes in the cardiovascular system, especially heart septal defects. A 2023 open-access review says transcatheter device closure is the preferred way of closing septum secundum defects and that careful patient selection and follow-up are necessary. A 2026 review says the indications, timing and long-term safety of patent foramen ovale closure remain controversial.",
  "summary_technical": "MeSH descriptor D055989, Septal Occluder Device (broad, because the descriptor names the implant and not the procedure). Its scope note describes a catheter-delivered implant used for closing abnormal holes in the cardiovascular system, especially heart septal defects. MedlinePlus lists cardiac catheterization to repair simple defects, such as a small hole in the inside wall of the heart, among the treatments for congenital heart defects. A 2023 open-access narrative review of closure devices for atrial septal defect (Cureus, CC BY 3.0) says transcatheter device closure is the preferred way of closing septum secundum defects; that a meta-analysis found the transcatheter approach had a high success rate and lower rates of adverse events and shorter hospital stays than surgery; and that complications are relatively rare. A 2026 open-access review of patent foramen ovale (MedComm, CC BY 4.0) says transcatheter closure has evolved into a secondary prevention strategy for patients with a PFO-related stroke, that apart from three randomized trials in stroke secondary prevention no other randomized trial has yielded encouraging results, and that long-term surveillance for arrhythmias and residual shunts is still needed. These are the reviews' statements; the atlas gives no rule about who should have an opening closed, by which route, or what medicine follows, and records no trial figures. The US approval of one device for secundum atrial septal defect is on that product's own page.",
  "editorial_state": "draft",
  "last_substantive_edit": "2026-11-18",
  "last_evidence_check": "2026-11-18",
  "next_review_due": null,
  "identifiers": [
    {
      "scheme": "mesh",
      "value": "D055989",
      "normalized_value": "D055989",
      "match": "broad",
      "version": "MeSH linked-data descriptor record fetched on 2026-11-18, lastUpdated 2010-01-01; the record states no yearly MeSH release",
      "label": null,
      "from_source": false
    }
  ],
  "navigation": {
    "cardio": {
      "system": [
        "heart"
      ],
      "condition-area": [
        "valvular-and-congenital-disease",
        "stroke"
      ]
    }
  },
  "payload": {
    "subtype": "procedure",
    "mechanism": "A catheter-delivered implant, carried by a thin tube guided through a vein into the heart, closes the opening (MeSH scope note; MedlinePlus).",
    "components": null
  },
  "content_digest": "0282e2149425c7be527744bb38787576a955e48f5c47edfc636b21264b6dd37e",
  "review": {
    "content_digest": "0282e2149425c7be527744bb38787576a955e48f5c47edfc636b21264b6dd37e",
    "current": [],
    "conflicting": [],
    "stale": [],
    "inactive": []
  },
  "claims": [
    {
      "release_id": "a25293eeae6350fb",
      "id": "cardio:claim-asd-device-closure-review",
      "owner": "cardio",
      "subject_entity_id": "cardio:closure-of-pfo-and-asd",
      "category": "descriptive",
      "statement": "A 2023 open-access narrative review of devices for transcatheter closure of atrial septal defect (Cureus) says transcatheter device closure is the preferred way of closing septum secundum defects. It says a meta-analysis found the transcatheter approach had a high success rate, lower rates of adverse events and shorter hospital stays compared with surgery, that complications have been reported but are relatively rare, and that careful patient selection and follow-up are necessary to minimize complications and ensure optimal outcomes. MedlinePlus lists cardiac catheterization to repair simple defects, such as a small hole in the inside wall of the heart, among the treatments for congenital heart defects.",
      "context": {
        "id": "cardio:ctx-asd-closure-review",
        "label": "People having an atrial septal defect closed (2023 device review)",
        "recipient": "unknown",
        "population": "People whose atrial septal defect is closed through a catheter, as the review describes them. It also covers some patients with a patent foramen ovale, and the comparison with surgery.",
        "care_setting": "Catheterization laboratory, as the review describes the procedure. Surgery is mentioned only as a comparison.",
        "geography": "The review discusses United States device approvals; this record does not use them.",
        "life_stage_note": "Not restricted in the abstract or introduction. The review includes studies of adults and of children; this record makes no statement about newborns, pregnancy or any age group.",
        "life_stage_terms": null,
        "gestational_age_min_days": null,
        "gestational_age_max_days": null,
        "gestational_age_basis": null,
        "postnatal_age_min_days": null,
        "postnatal_age_max_days": null,
        "gestational_age_status": null,
        "postnatal_age_status": null,
        "followup_description": "Not applicable (a narrative review; follow-up periods of individual studies are not recorded).",
        "eligibility": {
          "inclusion": [
            "Having an atrial septal defect that is closed through a catheter"
          ],
          "exclusion": []
        }
      },
      "evidence_stage": "synthesis",
      "certainty": "not_assessed",
      "certainty_method": null,
      "limitations": "A narrative review of devices, written in 2023; the outcome statements come from studies it cites, and its device list and trial figures are not repeated. The review mentions surgical closure only in comparison. The atlas states no rule about who should have a defect closed or by which route; the MedlinePlus sentence is general patient information.",
      "editorial_state": "draft",
      "checked_at": "2026-11-18",
      "next_review_due": null,
      "valid_from": null,
      "valid_to": null,
      "citations": [
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Introduction and background, para 1, sentence 9 (first part)",
          "applicability_note": "Transcatheter device closure is the preferred way to close septum secundum defects.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:50Z",
            "content_hash": "53c591583671de4cfe5e457b41f5d738ca323fdfed42568cf7b0c1dd76feec64",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Transcatheter Closure of Atrial Septal Defect: A Review of Currently Used Devices",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10329454/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC10329454",
                "normalized_value": "PMC10329454",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "37425612",
                "normalized_value": "37425612",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "normalized_value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "Cureus",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (Cureus 2023), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for what the review says about transcatheter closure of atrial septal defects; the device list and trial figures are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 3.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC10329454.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Abstract, para 1, sentence 15 (first part)",
          "applicability_note": "A meta-analysis found the transcatheter approach had a high success rate.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:50Z",
            "content_hash": "53c591583671de4cfe5e457b41f5d738ca323fdfed42568cf7b0c1dd76feec64",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Transcatheter Closure of Atrial Septal Defect: A Review of Currently Used Devices",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10329454/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC10329454",
                "normalized_value": "PMC10329454",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "37425612",
                "normalized_value": "37425612",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "normalized_value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "Cureus",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (Cureus 2023), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for what the review says about transcatheter closure of atrial septal defects; the device list and trial figures are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 3.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC10329454.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Abstract, para 1, sentence 15 (end)",
          "applicability_note": "Lower rates of adverse events and shorter hospital stays than surgery.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:50Z",
            "content_hash": "53c591583671de4cfe5e457b41f5d738ca323fdfed42568cf7b0c1dd76feec64",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Transcatheter Closure of Atrial Septal Defect: A Review of Currently Used Devices",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10329454/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC10329454",
                "normalized_value": "PMC10329454",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "37425612",
                "normalized_value": "37425612",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "normalized_value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "Cureus",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (Cureus 2023), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for what the review says about transcatheter closure of atrial septal defects; the device list and trial figures are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 3.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC10329454.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Abstract, para 1, sentence 16 (first part)",
          "applicability_note": "Complications of transcatheter closure have been reported.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:50Z",
            "content_hash": "53c591583671de4cfe5e457b41f5d738ca323fdfed42568cf7b0c1dd76feec64",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Transcatheter Closure of Atrial Septal Defect: A Review of Currently Used Devices",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10329454/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC10329454",
                "normalized_value": "PMC10329454",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "37425612",
                "normalized_value": "37425612",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "normalized_value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "Cureus",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (Cureus 2023), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for what the review says about transcatheter closure of atrial septal defects; the device list and trial figures are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 3.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC10329454.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Abstract, para 1, sentence 17",
          "applicability_note": "Complications are relatively rare.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:50Z",
            "content_hash": "53c591583671de4cfe5e457b41f5d738ca323fdfed42568cf7b0c1dd76feec64",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Transcatheter Closure of Atrial Septal Defect: A Review of Currently Used Devices",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10329454/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC10329454",
                "normalized_value": "PMC10329454",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "37425612",
                "normalized_value": "37425612",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "normalized_value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "Cureus",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (Cureus 2023), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for what the review says about transcatheter closure of atrial septal defects; the device list and trial figures are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 3.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC10329454.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Abstract, para 1, sentence 20",
          "applicability_note": "Careful patient selection and follow-up are necessary.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:50Z",
            "content_hash": "53c591583671de4cfe5e457b41f5d738ca323fdfed42568cf7b0c1dd76feec64",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc10329454",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Transcatheter Closure of Atrial Septal Defect: A Review of Currently Used Devices",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10329454/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC10329454",
                "normalized_value": "PMC10329454",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "37425612",
                "normalized_value": "37425612",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "normalized_value": "10.7759/cureus.40132",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "Cureus",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (Cureus 2023), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for what the review says about transcatheter closure of atrial septal defects; the device list and trial figures are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 3.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC10329454.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Summary, What are the treatments for congenital heart defects?",
          "applicability_note": "MedlinePlus: cardiac catheterization to repair simple defects.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:medlineplus-congenitalheartdefects-2026-10-14",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T18:21:54Z",
            "content_hash": "8a8235db9024c57a4d94c6eca43f79959079f4a59cadc7bbe15b9e7e583f480d",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:medlineplus-congenitalheartdefects",
            "source_type": "webpage",
            "title": "Congenital Heart Defects (MedlinePlus health topic)",
            "canonical_url": "https://medlineplus.gov/congenitalheartdefects.html",
            "identifiers": [],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "U.S. National Library of Medicine (MedlinePlus)",
            "edition": "Page fetched 2026-10-14. The page shows a last-updated date in its footer; it is not used here.",
            "reuse_basis": "MedlinePlus says works produced by the federal government are not copyrighted and that its summaries on health topic pages are in the public domain, and asks users to acknowledge MedlinePlus as the source (MedlinePlus using-content page, fetched 2026-10-14, hash only). Some images on MedlinePlus are copyrighted; this atlas uses none. The raw page is committed at research/snapshots/cj-medlineplus-congenitalheartdefects.html. Terms re-checked on 2026-11-08 at https://medlineplus.gov/about/using/usingcontent/ (page not committed; sha256 0825c88f5bd1dade7c8693bad8035b0d1f25fd0b8c5053e488c618fb2b62e722). That page says health topic page summaries, medical test information and Genetics page summaries are in the public domain, and that A.D.A.M. Medical Encyclopedia content (medlineplus.gov/ency/), ASHP drug monographs and most images are copyrighted. This source is a public-domain page, not an A.D.A.M. page, so public text stays quote; any A.D.A.M. page would be cite_only.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "context",
          "locator": "scopeNote.@value, sentence 1 (first part)",
          "applicability_note": "MeSH scope note for a septal occluder device.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:mesh-scope-d055989-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:23:30Z",
            "content_hash": "0bf9f56e8a4655464b7574c149341ac7e89f41d00cf0fa2f804e89c01d274f37",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:mesh-scope-d055989",
            "source_type": "dataset",
            "title": "MeSH scope note for descriptor D055989 (Septal Occluder Device)",
            "canonical_url": "https://id.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/M0524981",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "mesh",
                "value": "M0524981",
                "normalized_value": "M0524981",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": "id.nlm.nih.gov linked data, preferred concept M0524981 of descriptor D055989, retrieved 2026-11-18",
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "U.S. National Library of Medicine",
            "edition": "MeSH linked-data record of the preferred concept M0524981 of descriptor D055989, fetched 2026-11-18. The scope note is on this concept record, not on the descriptor record.",
            "reuse_basis": "The NLM web policies page (sha256 c8b7026b5c3fcfd1b0cb88755077f6a99a5f2159eecd42b0e7d1a5ad9b30ec55, hash only) says works produced by the U.S. government are not subject to copyright protection in the United States and asks users to acknowledge NLM as the source. The NLM MeSH terms and conditions page (sha256 f33b14141a5b6c8a2b1464c751dbdbb0a0d476c913851bf2a8c3d5c14b1afce7, hash only) asks redistributors to maintain current data or to make known that their copy may not reflect the most current data. This copy was fetched on 2026-11-18 and may not reflect the most current data. The raw bytes are committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-meshc-M0524981.json.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        }
      ],
      "review": {
        "content_digest": "a2ee3e71f1c4b278b3fe01fa662b686741b947d409971d94e12624507759dc4b",
        "current": [],
        "conflicting": [],
        "stale": [],
        "inactive": []
      },
      "api_path": "api/v1/claims/cardio--claim-asd-device-closure-review.json"
    },
    {
      "release_id": "a25293eeae6350fb",
      "id": "cardio:claim-pfo-closure-review",
      "owner": "cardio",
      "subject_entity_id": "cardio:closure-of-pfo-and-asd",
      "category": "descriptive",
      "statement": "A 2026 open-access review of patent foramen ovale (MedComm) says transcatheter closure has evolved into a secondary prevention strategy for patients with a PFO-related stroke, and that substantial evidence has established transcatheter closure for secondary prevention in patients with cryptogenic stroke. It says the indications, timing and long-term safety of closure remain controversial, that long-term surveillance for complications such as arrhythmias and residual shunts is still needed, and that apart from three randomized trials in stroke secondary prevention no other randomized trial has yielded encouraging results for closure.",
      "context": {
        "id": "cardio:ctx-pfo-closure-review",
        "label": "People having a patent foramen ovale closed (2026 review)",
        "recipient": "unknown",
        "population": "People with a patent foramen ovale whose closure is considered, mainly after a PFO-related stroke, as the review describes them.",
        "care_setting": "Not stated for the review as a whole. The review discusses the closure procedure and its follow-up.",
        "geography": "Not stated for the review as a whole.",
        "life_stage_note": "Not restricted. The review lists elderly people, children, pregnant women and athletes as groups in whom diagnostic and predictive tools need further investigation; this record makes no statement about them.",
        "life_stage_terms": null,
        "gestational_age_min_days": null,
        "gestational_age_max_days": null,
        "gestational_age_basis": null,
        "postnatal_age_min_days": null,
        "postnatal_age_max_days": null,
        "gestational_age_status": null,
        "postnatal_age_status": null,
        "followup_description": "Not applicable (a narrative review; follow-up periods of individual studies are not recorded).",
        "eligibility": {
          "inclusion": [
            "Having a patent foramen ovale",
            "Being considered for closure of a patent foramen ovale"
          ],
          "exclusion": []
        }
      },
      "evidence_stage": "synthesis",
      "certainty": "not_assessed",
      "certainty_method": null,
      "limitations": "A narrative review; the statements come from its abstract, introduction and conclusions, which cite the trials without giving figures here. The review uses the abbreviation CS for cryptogenic stroke. Trial figures, device types and patient-selection criteria are not repeated, and the atlas states no rule about who should have a patent foramen ovale closed.",
      "editorial_state": "draft",
      "checked_at": "2026-11-18",
      "next_review_due": null,
      "valid_from": null,
      "valid_to": null,
      "citations": [
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Introduction, para 2, sentence 4 (part)",
          "applicability_note": "Transcatheter closure has evolved into a secondary prevention strategy for PFO-related stroke.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:47Z",
            "content_hash": "f0b4ebb513263ec28c3efbbd9df9af28be224756753838bc1b172e0e6fb2a096",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Patent Foramen Ovale: Epidemiology, Risk Factors, Pathophysiology, Clinical Features, Diagnosis, and Management",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13547099/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC13547099",
                "normalized_value": "PMC13547099",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "42707360",
                "normalized_value": "42707360",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "normalized_value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "MedComm",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (MedComm 2026), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for how common a patent foramen ovale is, the conditions linked with it, and what the review says about closure; diagnostic detail and device types are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 4.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC13547099.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Conclusions and Perspectives, para 1, sentence 3",
          "applicability_note": "Substantial evidence has established closure for secondary prevention in cryptogenic stroke.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:47Z",
            "content_hash": "f0b4ebb513263ec28c3efbbd9df9af28be224756753838bc1b172e0e6fb2a096",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Patent Foramen Ovale: Epidemiology, Risk Factors, Pathophysiology, Clinical Features, Diagnosis, and Management",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13547099/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC13547099",
                "normalized_value": "PMC13547099",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "42707360",
                "normalized_value": "42707360",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "normalized_value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "MedComm",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (MedComm 2026), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for how common a patent foramen ovale is, the conditions linked with it, and what the review says about closure; diagnostic detail and device types are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 4.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC13547099.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Abstract, para 1, sentence 3 (end)",
          "applicability_note": "Indications, timing and long-term safety remain controversial.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:47Z",
            "content_hash": "f0b4ebb513263ec28c3efbbd9df9af28be224756753838bc1b172e0e6fb2a096",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Patent Foramen Ovale: Epidemiology, Risk Factors, Pathophysiology, Clinical Features, Diagnosis, and Management",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13547099/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC13547099",
                "normalized_value": "PMC13547099",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "42707360",
                "normalized_value": "42707360",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "normalized_value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "MedComm",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (MedComm 2026), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for how common a patent foramen ovale is, the conditions linked with it, and what the review says about closure; diagnostic detail and device types are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 4.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC13547099.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Conclusions and Perspectives, para 2, sentence 4 (end)",
          "applicability_note": "Long-term surveillance for complications such as arrhythmias and residual shunts is still needed.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:47Z",
            "content_hash": "f0b4ebb513263ec28c3efbbd9df9af28be224756753838bc1b172e0e6fb2a096",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Patent Foramen Ovale: Epidemiology, Risk Factors, Pathophysiology, Clinical Features, Diagnosis, and Management",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13547099/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC13547099",
                "normalized_value": "PMC13547099",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "42707360",
                "normalized_value": "42707360",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "normalized_value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "MedComm",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (MedComm 2026), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for how common a patent foramen ovale is, the conditions linked with it, and what the review says about closure; diagnostic detail and device types are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 4.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC13547099.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        },
        {
          "evidence_role": "supports",
          "locator": "Conclusions and Perspectives, para 3, sentence 1",
          "applicability_note": "Apart from three trials in stroke secondary prevention, no other randomized trial has yielded encouraging results.",
          "snapshot": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099-2026-11-18",
            "retrieved_at": "2026-11-18T17:25:47Z",
            "content_hash": "f0b4ebb513263ec28c3efbbd9df9af28be224756753838bc1b172e0e6fb2a096",
            "source_effective_date": null,
            "public_archive_url": null,
            "source_state": "current"
          },
          "source": {
            "id": "cardio:pmc-pmc13547099",
            "source_type": "publication",
            "title": "Patent Foramen Ovale: Epidemiology, Risk Factors, Pathophysiology, Clinical Features, Diagnosis, and Management",
            "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13547099/",
            "identifiers": [
              {
                "scheme": "pmcid",
                "value": "PMC13547099",
                "normalized_value": "PMC13547099",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "pmid",
                "value": "42707360",
                "normalized_value": "42707360",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              },
              {
                "scheme": "doi",
                "value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "normalized_value": "10.1002/mco2.70957",
                "match": "exact",
                "version": null,
                "label": null,
                "from_source": false
              }
            ],
            "publication_date": null,
            "publisher": "MedComm",
            "edition": "PMC Open Access subset full-text XML, from NCBI E-utilities (MedComm 2026), fetched 2026-11-18. A narrative review. Used for how common a patent foramen ovale is, the conditions linked with it, and what the review says about closure; diagnostic detail and device types are not used.",
            "reuse_basis": "PMC Open Access subset article under the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, content-type ccbylicense, CC BY 4.0). The article's own license element states the licence. The XML is committed unaltered, with the citation and licence kept in the file. The raw file is committed at research/snapshots/w4k12-pmc-PMC13547099.xml.",
            "public_text": "quote",
            "replaced_by": null,
            "retirement_note": null
          }
        }
      ],
      "review": {
        "content_digest": "d1a00f288b805bd40b2e889ac7c8ed55c4efd12d4765a1f563afd5db782fd8ae",
        "current": [],
        "conflicting": [],
        "stale": [],
        "inactive": []
      },
      "api_path": "api/v1/claims/cardio--claim-pfo-closure-review.json"
    }
  ],
  "decisions": [],
  "milestones": [],
  "relationships": {
    "outgoing": [
      {
        "predicate": "evaluated_for",
        "label": "A 2023 review says transcatheter device closure is the preferred way to close septum secundum defects; its outcome statements come from studies it cites",
        "clinical_claim_not_fact": true,
        "family": "clinical",
        "other_entity_id": "cardio:atrial-septal-defect",
        "other_entity_in_atlas": true,
        "claim_id": "cardio:claim-asd-device-closure-review",
        "evidence": null,
        "primary": false,
        "role": null,
        "valid_from": null,
        "valid_to": null
      },
      {
        "predicate": "evaluated_for",
        "label": "A 2026 review says closure is a secondary prevention strategy for PFO-related stroke, and that indications, timing and long-term safety remain controversial",
        "clinical_claim_not_fact": true,
        "family": "clinical",
        "other_entity_id": "cardio:patent-foramen-ovale",
        "other_entity_in_atlas": true,
        "claim_id": "cardio:claim-pfo-closure-review",
        "evidence": null,
        "primary": false,
        "role": null,
        "valid_from": null,
        "valid_to": null
      },
      {
        "predicate": "related_to",
        "label": "A closure device; its US approval covers secundum atrial septal defect closure through a catheter",
        "clinical_claim_not_fact": false,
        "family": "navigation",
        "other_entity_id": "cardio:amplatzer-septal-occluder",
        "other_entity_in_atlas": true,
        "claim_id": null,
        "evidence": null,
        "primary": false,
        "role": null,
        "valid_from": null,
        "valid_to": null
      },
      {
        "predicate": "part_of",
        "label": "Filed under this front",
        "clinical_claim_not_fact": false,
        "family": "navigation",
        "other_entity_id": "cardio:front-procedures-and-surgery",
        "other_entity_in_atlas": true,
        "claim_id": null,
        "evidence": null,
        "primary": true,
        "role": null,
        "valid_from": null,
        "valid_to": null
      }
    ],
    "incoming": []
  },
  "page_path": "interventions/closure-of-pfo-and-asd/",
  "context_path": "api/v1/context/cardio--closure-of-pfo-and-asd.md"
}
